2010 Recruits

[Jacked_Up]

Re: 2010 Recruits

Remember, too, that scholies can be taken away from existing holders. I don't think that's very common at SDSU, but it's happened. I remember, long ago, coach Jim Thorsen creating controversy by taking away some basketball skolies from a player or two. That doesn't seem to be Coach Nagy's style, however. He seems to remain loyal to recruits, from beginning to end.

[jackdaniel]

Re: 2010 Recruits

Maybe he meant by redshirting that yr, you won't draw off a scholarship for that year, but instead ,starting the scholarship period a year later,instead of 2010 scholarship, it would be offered as a 2011 scholarship, just guessing, don't even know if you can do that or not.Doing it that way , you would "salvage " another scholarship for a 2010 recruit, at the "expense" of a 2011 scholarship.

[mitchell]

Re: 2010 Recruits

I thought that was what they were doing with Brayden Carlson. He is walking-on this year with the promise of a scholarship next year.

[joeboo22]

Re: 2010 Recruits

I thought that was what they were doing with Brayden Carlson. He is walking-on this year with the promise of a scholarship next year.

In general those type of deals are for local recruits who aren't highly recruited.... Its hard to get a kid who has other offers and probably doesn't know much about SDSU to accept that type of a deal......

[TeaJackrabbit]

Re: 2010 Recruits

The last 5 posts are all pretty much correct.......from what I hear (even though I have learned that players are not always accurate on these types of issues) something is going to happen sooner than later. Whether that's the Davis schollie situation, someone leaving, someone losing/forfeiting a schollie, I'm not quite sure.

A program just pulling a schollie without just cause is very rare and not a good idea.

I would still like to get some info as to why the Gruis offer was pulled....not to mention if he had other offers other than USD. Not knocking USD (even though it's fun to do) but how attractive can it be to ink at USD right now? His signing there early and the fact that SDSU pulls his offer tells me something is up. It's just from what I've heard he's a much better player to have a school like SDSU (with an available schollie) pull an offer and to have him "settle" (my opinion) for USD. I guess I had some of the same questions (mainly why did he choose me-too-u) about Louie Krogman too.

[Billy Hoyle]

Re: 2010 Recruits

I would still like to get some info as to why the Gruis offer was pulled....not to mention if he had other offers other than USD. Not knocking USD (even though it's fun to do) but how attractive can it be to ink at USD right now? His signing there early and the fact that SDSU pulls his offer tells me something is up. It's just from what I've heard he's a much better player to have a school like SDSU (with an available schollie) pull an offer and to have him "settle" (my opinion) for USD. I guess I had some of the same questions (mainly why did he choose me-too-u) about Louie Krogman too.

My opinion...
1. A chance to have your education paid for at a good school.
2. The opportunity to play for a program that consistently wins 20 games a year in the Dakota Dome.
3. Are they poised to take some lumps the next couple of years...yes, but what an experience playing Texas Tech, Marquette, Oregon State, Kansas State & Drake. His sophomore year they join the Summit and his Jr. & Sr. they are fully eligible for tourneys. Maybe being part of this process would be challenging & rewarding for the young man?
4. They fell in love with Dykstra and all chips are in on his commitment. Trevor knew that and has moved on (with some extra motivation when these schools square off in the future).

[Patkran]

Re: 2010 Recruits

SDSU offered Gruis and he told them he wanted to wait and see. They waited a couple months and then SDSU made a decision that they were not going to recruit Trevor anymore. That has been a common theme this summer for some kids in the upper Midwest, they get an offer, they want to see if someone better is going to offer too, then the scholarship goes to someone else. My guess is that USD was the best offer on the table and Gruis took it. That is smart on his part. He will do well there and he is a good fit for that system. Trevor got a DI scholarship, but the focus has been on why SDSU stopped recruiting him. Coach Nagy went a different direction, that happens alot on the recruitment of athletes.

[jackmd]

Re: 2010 Recruits

SDSU offered Gruis and he told them he wanted to wait and see. They waited a couple months and then SDSU made a decision that they were not going to recruit Trevor anymore. That has been a common theme this summer for some kids in the upper Midwest, they get an offer, they want to see if someone better is going to offer too, then the scholarship goes to someone else. My guess is that USD was the best offer on the table and Gruis took it. That is smart on his part. He will do well there and he is a good fit for that system. Trevor got a DI scholarship, but the focus has been on why SDSU stopped recruiting him. Coach Nagy went a different direction, that happens alot on the recruitment of athletes.

I've only spoken to those affiliated with the SDSU program and not experts like Billy H. and the information in the post by Patkran is what I have been lead to understand. Trevor was offered, balked and then our staff decided to move in a different direction. I have no idea what other offers he had. When interviewed he stated that the program at USD fit him well and that he felt he could get an excellent education there. I think he is right on both counts.

I'd just like to remind Billy H. that we consistently won 20 plus games per year and made many more regionals than any of the other DII schools in the region during our DII era.

[filbert]

Re: 2010 Recruits

I'm not sure how high school athletes get the notion that scholarship offers are forever, or that they're the only kid in the world that a coaching staff is looking at to fill a slot on the college team.

They're definitely limited-time offers and can expire whenever the coaches offering the scholarship decide to go in another direction, or whenever another kid decides to say "yes." (Of course, some coaching staffs are better than others at explaining this uncomfortable little detail, but that's life, too. You have to hope that ours are among the more forthright coaches--I think that' s the culture most of us want at SDSU as alumni and fans, anyway.)

I guess it's all part of the immaturity of teenagers, combined with the people around them giving questionable, or even outright unreasonable advice.

[Billy Hoyle]

Re: 2010 Recruits

I've only spoken to those affiliated with the SDSU program and not experts like Billy H. and the information in the post by Patkran is what I have been lead to understand. Trevor was offered, balked and then our staff decided to move in a different direction. I have no idea what other offers he had. When interviewed he stated that the program at USD fit him well and that he felt he could get an excellent education there. I think he is right on both counts.

I'd just like to remind Billy H. that we consistently won 20 plus games per year and made many more regionals than any of the other DII schools in the region during our DII era.

Never, ever claimed to be an expert...the question was asked and I clearly stated it was my "opinion" on why Trevor chose USD. Never compared USD's 20 win seasons to SDSU or any other successful program....just a reason why he might choose USD. I am not a SDSU hater or a USD alum, just someone who knows MN basketball pretty well.
Only 4 MN basketball recruits have signed right now. Official visits can start after high school starts. The early signing period is Nov. 11-18 and programs that really want players will wait until at least then. Fact is, SDSU wasn't in love with Gruis enough to wait. They are in love with Dykstra.
We do agree that USD will be a good fit for Trevor and that he will get a good education there.

[jackmd]

Re: 2010 Recruits

Never, ever claimed to be an expert...the question was asked and I clearly stated it was my "opinion" on why Trevor chose USD. Never compared USD's 20 win seasons to SDSU or any other successful program....just a reason why he might choose USD. I am not a SDSU hater or a USD alum, just someone who knows MN basketball pretty well.
Only 4 MN basketball recruits have signed right now. Official visits can start after high school starts. The early signing period is Nov. 11-18 and programs that really want players will wait until at least then. Fact is, SDSU wasn't in love with Gruis enough to wait. They are in love with Dykstra.
We do agree that USD will be a good fit for Trevor and that he will get a good education there.

I understood your position just wanted to add my perspective on the issue. We are definitely looking at it from two different sides. As for the extra incentive, not sure that will be needed. When we play the boys from Vermillion again it will be plenty intense regardless.

[SFJACK]

Re: 2010 Recruits

So i'm not sure if this is new news, but I was informed by someone I would consider a reliable source, the earliest Dykstra would commit is October.

[JACKGUYII]

Re: 2010 Recruits

I have to think if the Davis situation is resolved soon and SDSU has a scholarship to give the verbal could come before the official signing in October.

[TeaJackrabbit]

Re: 2010 Recruits

My opinion...
1. A chance to have your education paid for at a good school.
2. The opportunity to play for a program that consistently wins 20 games a year in the Dakota Dome.
3. Are they poised to take some lumps the next couple of years...yes, but what an experience playing Texas Tech, Marquette, Oregon State, Kansas State & Drake. His sophomore year they join the Summit and his Jr. & Sr. they are fully eligible for tourneys. Maybe being part of this process would be challenging & rewarding for the young man?
4. They fell in love with Dykstra and all chips are in on his commitment. Trevor knew that and has moved on (with some extra motivation when these schools square off in the future).

Thanks for wieghing in and adding to the discussion Billy.....

My .02 -

Playing in the Dakotadome is no treat. And the 20 every year is kind of silly. Last year (last few years?) their schedule was pretty pathetic. But hey, 20 wins is 20 wins I guess and I'm the guy saying SDSU's schedule is TOO tough this year.

I'm sure playing some of those schools will be fun, but how fun is it to lose by 20+?

I just have to trust Nagy at this point....and I do. Like I said, if Gruis is really that great the kid would be somewhere other than a transitional D1 school. Like we've discussed on here different kids pick different schools for different reasons and that is their business and should be respected. But with all we've heard you'd think schools like UNI, Montana, Mont St, Wyoming, Drake, UWGB, UW-Mil, etc would be more on this kid (and maybe they were, I dunno).

A good competitor is always looking for extra motivation, so I wouldn't blame him there. But SDSU did nothing wrong. SDSU put an offer on the table, he didn't take it, SDSU moved on. SDSU can play against him with equal motivation. I'd tell my kids in the locker room that he had a chance to join the family but didn't. Works both ways.

[TeaJackrabbit]

Re: 2010 Recruits

I have to think if the Davis situation is resolved soon and SDSU has a scholarship to give the verbal could come before the official signing in October.

I could be wrong but I think a kid could verbal right now even if there are no available schollies....