HIGHS and lows.

[1stRowFANatic]

Re: HIGHS and lows.

I don't think you can say last years class is anywhere near as good as this years. You have to add White and Braydon to the class with the Rock Valley kids. That's 3/4 really solid players. Last years class only has Wolters, Rader and Feigen. There are 2 good players with an unknown but the 2 Rock Valley kids are better than them and the you add 2 more good players.

No, you can't add White and Carlson to next years class. They started school this year. If you are going to do that, you can't include the Rock Valley kids in next years class because you have no idea whether or not they are going to redshirt next year. Remember White is redshirting because of an injury and the same thing could happen to Fiegen or Wolters next year, or any of the incoming freshman.

I think the only way to compare recruiting classes is to look at the year they come to SDSU, and usually the evaluation shouldn't be done for a couple of years, but that wouldn't be any fun.

[91jack]

Re: HIGHS and lows.

No, you can't add White and Carlson to next years class. They started school this year. If you are going to do that, you can't include the Rock Valley kids in next years class because you have no idea whether or not they are going to redshirt next year. Remember White is redshirting because of an injury and the same thing could happen to Fiegen or Wolters next year, or any of the incoming freshman.

I think the only way to compare recruiting classes is to look at the year they come to SDSU, and usually the evaluation shouldn't be done for a couple of years, but that wouldn't be any fun.

Good points!
I guess it makes more sense that way.
I was just looking at it as the classes hit the court. Even though last year's class was a deeper more well rounded one, you can't really see the dividends until they hit the court. If you are saying that Nagy's team isn't making as much progress as you want, they have more talent coming in (and probably playing) next year over this one. And there is/will be some real progress this year.