Transfers Leaving

[SDSUAlum08]

Re: Transfers Leaving

Everyone shouldn't get their pink panties all in a bunch....locusts aren't coming, we aren't getting nuked by North Korea, etc.... the whole team is not gonna transfer. When Saul Phillips left NDSU there wasn't a mass exodus, the program continued and thrived just fine. They will have good candidates to pick from, just don't all go hanging yourselves all at once now, the athletic department will need all the donations from all you rich, know it all people to hire the new coach.

Your name and location makes this even better.

[TK22867]

Re: Transfers Leaving

That's kind of disingenuous, right? A big reason a lot of kids commit is for the coach. The coach can leave whenever he or she wants, regardless of contract, and the kid is stuck?

I thought the Houston Cougars coach had a really good quote on that, when he was asked about transfers and coaches.



VIA

It could be, yes, but every student athlete knows of this before they sign. That's the breaks. Life isn't always fair.

[JackJD]

Re: Transfers Leaving

TK makes a valid point. Everyone might not agree. Note that when a coach leaves, there usually is not a mass exodus.

i have deleted posts that refer to specific athletes who might transfer -- that is only speculation right now. Filbert's attribution rule in the Board Guidelines has not been followed.

Some posters have pointed out that some tweets about Nagy telling the player by phone appears to be incorrect. Situations like this seem to invite misinformation as people are scrambling for info.

[JackJD]

Re: Transfers Leaving

One can find some humor in this thread. GrimReaper appears at post 45--only his second post since joining in April, 2015. You can click on his name and a drop down box appears--choose view all posts. That will bring up his first post made in December. It's pretty funny (ends with "vote for Trump"). MontanaRabbit's reply "Eric, is that you?" Made me laugh too.

[Nidaros]

Re: Transfers Leaving

Everyone shouldn't get their pink panties all in a bunch....locusts aren't coming, we aren't getting nuked by North Korea, etc.... the whole team is not gonna transfer. When Saul Phillips left NDSU there wasn't a mass exodus, the program continued and thrived just fine. They will have good candidates to pick from, just don't all go hanging yourselves all at once now, the athletic department will need all the donations from all you rich, know it all people to hire the new coach.

Some truth here. Also gave rep pts. I hate to see anyone in the red on reputation points, even the devil does not deserve that.

[MontanaRabbit]

Re: Transfers Leaving

It could be, yes, but every student athlete knows of this before they sign. That's the breaks. Life isn't always fair.

I tend to agree. It's been a hot topic recently on the football side of things with schools limiting where kids can transfer.

[jack power]

Re: Transfers Leaving

No AD in their right mind is going prevent an athlete from transferring after a coach leaves. They're not indentured servants.

[bigticket1]

Re: Transfers Leaving

No AD in their right mind is going prevent an athlete from transferring after a coach leaves. They're not indentured servants.

Maybe so, but if that AD has his right mind, he's not going to allow it to happen until after the new coach is hired and has had a chance to meet with the players.

[bigticket1]

Re: Transfers Leaving

That's kind of disingenuous, right? A big reason a lot of kids commit is for the coach. The coach can leave whenever he or she wants, regardless of contract, and the kid is stuck?

I thought the Houston Cougars coach had a really good quote on that, when he was asked about transfers and coaches.



VIA

So using that logic, if a coach is fired than all the players should lose their scholarships since they committed to the coach and not the school ?

[slosho]

Re: Transfers Leaving

There is a year of eligibility to lose with a transfer as well, unless you move down. That's a lot to lose.

Sent from my SM-N900V using Tapatalk

[Nidaros]

Re: Transfers Leaving

So using that logic, if a coach is fired than all the players should lose their scholarships since they committed to the coach and not the school ?

I think we can conclude, they are all under contract, but different terms and for different purposes. I think if a SA has found a major he/she is comfortable with they seem less likely to leave. They came for an education and a BB career is secondary. Life is about making a living and not playing games. That is the ones we like to watch as fans. It will all work out.

[RabbitObsessed]

Re: Transfers Leaving

No AD in their right mind is going prevent an athlete from transferring after a coach leaves. They're not indentured servants.

Yet it happens all across the country.

[RabbitObsessed]

Re: Transfers Leaving

So using that logic, if a coach is fired than all the players should lose their scholarships since they committed to the coach and not the school ?

That seems like quite the strawman argument.

[JackJD]

Re: Transfers Leaving

There is a year of eligibility to lose with a transfer as well, unless you move down. That's a lot to lose.

Sent from my SM-N900V using Tapatalk

Sure about that? Subject to various exceptions (e.g. Medical), an athlete has four years of eligibility to use in five years. If the athlete transfers, they sit out a year but do no lose a year just for transferring (assuming a redshirt year wasn't taken or other exceptions apply). Example: If Slosho played two years as a shooting guard at Duke and then transferred to SDSU, he would sit a year. After sitting a year, he could play two years for the Jacks.

[TK22867]

Re: Transfers Leaving

Enough of this transfer talk of the remaining players. Here's a Stuart Smalley Monday morning positive vibe for you. Our new coach is going to be so well received by the current players, fans, and alumni, that not only will the current players stay , but our new coach will bring in some big-time JUCOs to compliment Daum, Telly, and the others and will put us right back in the NCAA Tourney next year. BOOM!