Potential new redshirt rule allows freshman to play in up to 4 games while redshirtin

[WestSideRabbit]

Re: Potential new redshirt rule allows freshman to play in up to 4 games while redshi

Isn't he hurt? I thought he would slide into Dallas play making role.

Was injured. He has been passed by Blake Kunz on the depth chart.

[JacksBacker]

Re: Potential new redshirt rule allows freshman to play in up to 4 games while redshi

A tweet from Deyon Campbell last night FWIW.

https://twitter.com/deyon_campbell6/...94376563691520

[WestSideRabbit]

Re: Potential new redshirt rule allows freshman to play in up to 4 games while redshi

Here is where the current freshmen are at in terms of participation in relation to the 4 game rule.
All 3 games: Blake Kunz, Caleb Sanders, CJ Wilson
2 games: Mason McCormick
1 game: Ian Bass, Garrett Greenfield, Max Howard, Cade Terveer

[goon]

Re: Potential new redshirt rule allows freshman to play in up to 4 games while redshi

Was injured. He has been passed by Blake Kunz on the depth chart.

I really thought skyler would have passed hart on the depth chart.

[Nidaros]

Re: Potential new redshirt rule allows freshman to play in up to 4 games while redshi

Here is our current WR depth:
X: Adam Anderson, Jadon Janke, Jaxon Janke
Z: Jacob Brown, Isaiah Hill, Michael Wandmaker, Jayd Vanderwerff
W: Cade Johnson, Marquise Lewis, Deyon Campbell, Jake Aanderud

Jacob and Cade are dinged up and Marquise and Deyon are probably a week or two from being back. One more injury and we are trotting out true freshmen, redshirt freshmen or walk-on redshirts at a position that is challenging to learn for most. This is a big deal and I'm pretty surprised that no one else seems concerned about this.

If you are concerned, then I am concerned. You are the insider here with the information.

[Jacks-02]

Re: Potential new redshirt rule allows freshman to play in up to 4 games while redshi

Here is where the current freshmen are at in terms of participation in relation to the 4 game rule.
All 3 games: Blake Kunz, Caleb Sanders, CJ Wilson
2 games: Mason McCormick
1 game: Ian Bass, Garrett Greenfield, Max Howard, Cade Terveer

Are we 100% sure the ISU game doesn't count? I've heard rumors that it does.

[RabbitObsessed]

Re: Potential new redshirt rule allows freshman to play in up to 4 games while redshi

It's his life. He gave over 3 years and like you said he gave a year earlier than he should have. He wants to play, can't fault him for that.

Big agree. I will never, ever fault a player for making a choice about their own life, education, and athletic career. I think it's selfish to refer to him transferring as "****ty and selfish."

[WestSideRabbit]

Re: Potential new redshirt rule allows freshman to play in up to 4 games while redshi

Are we 100% sure the ISU game doesn't count? I've heard rumors that it does.

It's not showing up on the participation list so I'm assuming no. Could be wrong I guess.

[UWMandSDSU]

Re: Potential new redshirt rule allows freshman to play in up to 4 games while redshi

Are we 100% sure the ISU game doesn't count? I've heard rumors that it does.

I asked Zim on Twitter about this after IA St. game was cancelled. He didn't know but then tweeted that it didn't count a couple days later.
https://twitter.com/argusmattz/statu...89615190593536

[goon]

Re: Potential new redshirt rule allows freshman to play in up to 4 games while redshi

How many freshman played on the 4 minutes of game time at Iowa state?

[WestSideRabbit]

Re: Potential new redshirt rule allows freshman to play in up to 4 games while redshi

How many freshman played on the 4 minutes of game time at Iowa state?

CJ Wilson and Kunz forsure. Did Sanders?

[westernjack]

Re: Potential new redshirt rule allows freshman to play in up to 4 games while redshi

Big agree. I will never, ever fault a player for making a choice about their own life, education, and athletic career. I think it's selfish to refer to him transferring as "****ty and selfish."

I highly doubt his education had anything to do with this choice. Otherwise I don't think he would have waited until part way through his senior season to transfer. I don't understand why he wouldn't want to be a part of a team that is likely going to be making a strong push at a national championship at the FCS level vs dropping down to D2 or NAIA for 1 year of possible playing time. He should have gone to a smaller school where he would have been the top dog from the start if that is his main objective with college athletics. But to each his own.

[Nidaros]

Re: Potential new redshirt rule allows freshman to play in up to 4 games while redshi

I highly doubt his education had anything to do with this choice. Otherwise I don't think he would have waited until part way through his senior season to transfer. I don't understand why he wouldn't want to be a part of a team that is likely going to be making a strong push at a national championship at the FCS level vs dropping down to D2 or NAIA for 1 year of possible playing time. He should have gone to a smaller school where he would have been the top dog from the start if that is his main objective with college athletics. But to each his own.

I have no idea how much financial aid Alex received in stay with SDSU football program, but apparently it was not enough to bother his conscience. What little information that has been presented on this board is not enough to draw any conclusions.

[Theee Catrabbit]

Re: Potential new redshirt rule allows freshman to play in up to 4 games while redshi

Here is our current WR depth:
X: Adam Anderson, Jadon Janke, Jaxon Janke
Z: Jacob Brown, Isaiah Hill, Michael Wandmaker, Jayd Vanderwerff
W: Cade Johnson, Marquise Lewis, Deyon Campbell, Jake Aanderud

Jacob and Cade are dinged up and Marquise and Deyon are probably a week or two from being back. One more injury and we are trotting out true freshmen, redshirt freshmen or walk-on redshirts at a position that is challenging to learn for most. This is a big deal and I'm pretty surprised that no one else seems concerned about this.

ok. well....we were always one play away from not having Weineke and Goedert. We're always one play away from not having anyone. We're two plays away from being on our 3rd string QB.

If it gets that bad we switch to a one WR set and commit to the run. I think we'll be ok. You have 11 WR's listed. I feel that's more than we have ever had in the past. Why worry? It's gonna be ok

[WestSideRabbit]

Re: Potential new redshirt rule allows freshman to play in up to 4 games while redshi

ok. well....we were always one play away from not having Weineke and Goedert. We're always one play away from not having anyone. We're two plays away from being on our 3rd string QB.

If it gets that bad we switch to a one WR set and commit to the run. I think we'll be ok. You have 11 WR's listed. I feel that's more than we have ever had in the past. Why worry? It's gonna be ok

Okay. I'll take your word for it!