Mid Major blues at Robert Morris

[OldHare]

https://www.fanragsports.com/cbb/ada...sfer-epidemic/

[Justwin]

Re: Mid Major blues at Robert Morris

https://www.fanragsports.com/cbb/ada...sfer-epidemic/

Lets hope we are not featured in that story after next year.

[bigticket1]

Re: Mid Major blues at Robert Morris

If this trend continues, the days of mid-major programs red-shirting players may be over, unless necessary because of injuries.

[Southeast]

Re: Mid Major blues at Robert Morris

A couple of years of this happening to star players on "my" team would make me lose interest in the sport real quick. The Jacks sure benefited from graduate transfers last season but I'd love to see the rule get changed. Mid-majors are at enough of a disadvantage between the scheduling challenges and lack of at-large tournament selections.

[jacks1]

Re: Mid Major blues at Robert Morris

If this trend continues, the days of mid-major programs red-shirting players may be over, unless necessary because of injuries.

Or the opposite. Once you redshirt, the only way you are transferring (aside from medical or rare family reasons) without losing a year of eligibility is: A) Transferring down in division, or B) being eligible as a grad transfer. Had Daum not redshirted, his ability to transfer and sit, without losing a year, would have been a lot hotter topic...

[Justwin]

Re: Mid Major blues at Robert Morris

If this trend continues, the days of mid-major programs red-shirting players may be over, unless necessary because of injuries.

I'm not sure that would be a bad thing. Teams are built in an entirely different way now than they were 10 years ago. Coaches are expected to win Now not later.

[RabbitObsessed]

Re: Mid Major blues at Robert Morris

Controversial take: I think all players should be able to transfer wherever they want without any sitting out or anything.

[Justwin]

Re: Mid Major blues at Robert Morris

Controversial take: I think all players should be able to transfer wherever they want without any sitting out or anything.

They would never have to eat vegetables...

[CappinHard]

Re: Mid Major blues at Robert Morris

A couple of years of this happening to star players on "my" team would make me lose interest in the sport real quick.

I completely agree. That's part of the reason why I love mid major sports so much, because you can watch players like Zenner, Wolters, Wieneke, Goedert, and Daum for 4 years without worrying about them jump ship to go to a higher level, or even to the pros.

[jacks1]

Re: Mid Major blues at Robert Morris

I completely agree. That's part of the reason why I love mid major sports so much, because you can watch players like Zenner, Wolters, Wieneke, Goedert, and Daum for 4 years without worrying about them jump ship to go to a higher level, or even to the pros.

Careful...

[CappinHard]

Re: Mid Major blues at Robert Morris

Careful...

Honestly, I don't see it. What would be the benefit? If he would transfer, it had better be a top tier program, and if he does that he won't be the star and might not even start on some of them. If he stays at SDSU and racks up stats, he'll get drafted and get his shot, just like he would if he transferred.

[jacks1]

Re: Mid Major blues at Robert Morris

Honestly, I don't see it. What would be the benefit? If he would transfer, it had better be a top tier program, and if he does that he won't be the star and might not even start on some of them. If he stays at SDSU and racks up stats, he'll get drafted and get his shot, just like he would if he transferred.

He won't transfer...but another monster year and an agent 'promising' that you'll be a 1st round pick if you declare...

Sent from my SCH-I545 using Tapatalk

[CappinHard]

Re: Mid Major blues at Robert Morris

He won't transfer...but another monster year and an agent 'promising' that you'll be a 1st round pick if you declare...

Sent from my SCH-I545 using Tapatalk

I feel like he's smart enough to realize that he's still got plenty to work on and that any 'promising' would be false. If he came out now, I don't know if he even gets drafted. Another big year and he could probably secure a draft spot, but at that point you might as well finish it out and secure an education.

[BTownJack]

Re: Mid Major blues at Robert Morris

To me the biggest worry is having him leave as a grad transfer after his 4th year at SDSU (leaving 1 year of eligibility left) - which is very possible. That is the downfall of red-shirting players now. You are guarded that they lose a year of eligibility if they transfer during their career as stated above. But it gives them a year head start academically which means they are more likely in a position to graduate and transfer.

[filbert]

Re: Mid Major blues at Robert Morris

So . . . playing and winning the "play-in" game . . . good thing for Robert Morris, or bad thing for Robert Morris?