2016 Recruits

[SanDakotaState]

Re: 2016 Recruits

I'm betting that Nagy is waiting on a grad transfer and/or JUCO guard.

[NebraskaJack]

Re: 2016 Recruits

Not according to.....

http://www.verbalcommits.com/schools/south-dakota-state

[OldHare]

Re: 2016 Recruits

Was there another commit other than Loudon Vollbrecht?

[GoldCountryJack]

Re: 2016 Recruits

Here's to hoping the Jacks take a pass on Dearing. He had two offers coming out of high school. Pretty much the entire state of Mn saw the Wis offer as a way to win favor for one of his AAU teammates in Rashad Vaughn. He was just an okay HS player at Minnetonka. No where near the player George is nor is he as athletic as say Flatten. I don't mind the transfer concept at all and think we will be a school upper midwest kids will consider based on our success and future. Better options for the Jacks than this player.

[jack power]

Re: 2016 Recruits

He missed 4 games with a concussion, then just had trouble finding playing time after that.

[MontanaRabbit]

Re: 2016 Recruits

I was asking about significant time that would lead to a medical redshirt, not a few games (4), which I think he missed w/ the concussion.

I thought he missed most of a season with some ailment. I could be wrong though. The important part is he hasn't missed TWO seasons with injury so a medical redshirt is not an option.

[UWMandSDSU]

Re: 2016 Recruits

Isn't that how he kinda landed in our lap? Got hurt (concussion?) and then was out of the rotation by the time he was cleared...

I was asking about significant time that would lead to a medical redshirt, not a few games (4), which I think he missed w/ the concussion.

[jacks1]

Re: 2016 Recruits

And I wasn't aware George had missed any significant time while at Wisconsin.

Isn't that how he kinda landed in our lap? Got hurt (concussion?) and then was out of the rotation by the time he was cleared...

[UWMandSDSU]

Re: 2016 Recruits

And I wasn't aware George had missed any significant time while at Wisconsin.

[Kemo]

Re: 2016 Recruits

We've discussed this several times, but in order to qualify for a medical redshirt exception doesn't the athlete have to miss most of two seasons due to injury? One RS year and another year where they are hurt doesn't work.......right???

Right. The player has to miss basically 2 full seasons due to injury in order to get a medical hardship. They technically can play a little in the season, but it's like less than a third of the games and it has to be in the first half of the season, not the second half.

[Kemo]

Re: 2016 Recruits

Flatten also??? Or maybe he doesn't qualify since first redshirt year wasn't injury related...

Skyler would have to have medical records that prove he was redshirted due to an injury, plus, he couldn't come back and play this year (or he'd have to miss a year later on) in order to get a hardship.

[MontanaRabbit]

Re: 2016 Recruits

Flatten also??? Or maybe he doesn't qualify since first redshirt year wasn't injury related...

We've discussed this several times, but in order to qualify for a medical redshirt exception doesn't the athlete have to miss most of two seasons due to injury? One RS year and another year where they are hurt doesn't work.......right???

[jacks1]

Re: 2016 Recruits

I wonder if George would ever be able to apply for a medical hardship year based upon time missed over career?

Flatten also??? Or maybe he doesn't qualify since first redshirt year wasn't injury related...

[Hip2daHop]

Re: 2016 Recruits

I wonder if George would ever be able to apply for a medical hardship year based upon time missed over career?

I'm terrible when it comes to evaluating whether or not SDSU should be in on players. I thought Parks and Marshall wouldn't fit in, I thought others would be studs who weren't and so on.

But my view on this transfer is don't be in on him, because he is a transfer from Wisconsin, if the coaches feel he'll fit in and help the team, then I'm fine with it, if they feel there are better options out there go for it.

To that point here is my view point

He wasn't that highly recruited out of high school, Drake, Illinois State and Wisconsin. And since going to Wisconsin he has been banged up, and when healthy still hasn't played much.

At the same time, big physical guards who get offered scholarships by program like Wisconsin don't grow on trees, and a change could flip the switch and he could be an awesome player.

[joeboo22]

Re: 2016 Recruits

I'm terrible when it comes to evaluating whether or not SDSU should be in on players. I thought Parks and Marshall wouldn't fit in, I thought others would be studs who weren't and so on.

But my view on this transfer is don't be in on him, because he is a transfer from Wisconsin, if the coaches feel he'll fit in and help the team, then I'm fine with it, if they feel there are better options out there go for it.

To that point here is my view point

He wasn't that highly recruited out of high school, Drake, Illinois State and Wisconsin. And since going to Wisconsin he has been banged up, and when healthy still hasn't played much.

At the same time, big physical guards who get offered scholarships by program like Wisconsin don't grow on trees, and a change could flip the switch and he could be an awesome player.